Shortlisting a PEM electrolyzer supplier starts with your purchase specification. A supplier suitable for an OEM stack programme may offer a different scope from one supplying a complete hydrogen-generation system. Compare evidence against the equipment and project you actually need.
This scorecard is a buyer’s evaluation framework, not a ranking of manufacturers. Use it to decide which proposals deserve an engineering discussion and a detailed RFQ.
Review systems and stacks · Prepare the document check · Discuss your requirements
1. Set the essential requirements before scoring
Record application, hydrogen demand and reference conditions, delivered gas quality, outlet pressure, operating profile, utilities, destination, quantity and target delivery. Mark whether the purchase is a stack, a complete system or an engineered package.
Identify requirements that must be resolved before purchase, including the operating envelope, safety and integration responsibilities, and documentation required for the destination. A high weighted score does not compensate for an unresolved essential requirement.
2. Use the same evidence-based scorecard for each proposal
| Criterion | Example weight | Evidence to request |
|---|---|---|
| Product and application fit | 20% | Selected model, operating duty and application limitations |
| Technical data quality | 20% | Revision-controlled specifications, test conditions and performance boundaries |
| Supply and interface clarity | 15% | Included equipment, options, exclusions and purchaser responsibilities |
| Testing and traceability | 15% | Agreed FAT scope, measurable criteria and equipment identification |
| Applicable documentation | 10% | Documents relevant to the actual model, supplier role and destination |
| Integration and service support | 10% | Technical contact, commissioning boundary, training and spare-parts proposal |
| Commercial and delivery clarity | 10% | Itemised quotation, validity, delivery dependencies and warranty terms |
3. Score what is demonstrated, not what is advertised
A simple scale is: 0 = not provided; 1 = a claim without supporting detail; 2 = documents supplied with conditions or questions still open; 3 = evidence reviewed and acceptable for the requested configuration.
With weights expressed as percentages, calculate the total as the sum of each weight multiplied by its score divided by three. Keep the underlying documents and open questions alongside the score. This produces an internal comparison, not an independent certification of a supplier.
Separate “not applicable” from “missing.” A bare stack proposal should not be marked as a complete system merely because it lists hydrogen output; the missing auxiliary equipment may belong to the integrator’s scope.
4. Hold a focused technical clarification meeting
- Which operating point supports the quoted hydrogen output and energy consumption?
- Where are purity, moisture and pressure specified and measured?
- Who provides DC power, water circulation, cooling, drying, controls and system safety?
- Which tests and records will identify the equipment supplied?
- What assumptions, exclusions and design changes could affect price or delivery?
For an OEM purchase, use our PEM stack interface checklist. For a complete package, start with the system product range.
5. Move from shortlist to a comparable RFQ
Send the same requirement and scope sheet to shortlisted suppliers. Ask them to label every item as included, optional, purchaser-supplied or awaiting confirmation. Record technical deviations and resolve them before comparing the commercial offers.
A laboratory team with provisional requirements can still start a selection discussion. Explain what the experiment must do and request help defining the unknowns; an incomplete initial brief should lead to clarification rather than an unsupported equipment recommendation.
Supplier-shortlisting questions
Should price decide the shortlist?
Price is relevant after the minimum technical and delivery requirements are understood. Compare the same equipment boundary and acceptance conditions.
Does a certificate establish every product’s suitability?
Check the issuing body, holder, validity and applicable equipment scope. Company-level documentation does not by itself establish every model’s performance.
Check whether HELE fits your procurement brief
Hele Titanium supplies PEM stacks and supports system and OEM project discussions. Send your company or institution, application, destination, required output, gas quality, pressure and project stage. Tell us which evidence your procurement process needs.
Published by Hele Titanium Hydrogen. Updated 17 October 2026. The example weights are an editable buyer framework; no supplier scores or rankings are implied.





